Subject and object questions
Who called you? vs Who did you call?
Most questions in English use a helper verb like do, does or did. But some questions do not need it. It depends on whether you are asking about the subject (the person or thing that does the action) or the object (the person or thing that receives the action).
When to use it
1. Subject questions ask who or what does the action. The question word is the subject.
- Who called you? (Someone called you. I want to know who.)
- What happened at the meeting?
2. Object questions ask who or what receives the action. The question word is the object.
- Who did you call? (You called someone. I want to know who.)
- What did Maria buy?
Look at the difference:
- Anna helped Tom. → Who helped Tom? Anna. (subject question)
- Anna helped Tom. → Who did Anna help? Tom. (object question)
3. Other question words work the same way: what, which, whose, how many and how much. They are often followed by a noun.
- Which team won the match? (subject)
- Which team did you support? (object)
- How many people came to the party? (subject)
How to form it
| Type | Structure | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Subject question | Question word + verb | Who lives here? / Who called you? |
| Object question | Question word + do/does/did + subject + verb | Who do you live with? / Who did you call? |
| Subject question (negative) | Question word + doesn't/didn't + verb | Who didn't come to class? |
| Object question (negative) | Question word + don't/didn't + subject + verb | What didn't you understand? |
| Subject question (other tenses) | Question word + auxiliary + verb | Who has taken my pen? / What is making that noise? |
| Object question (other tenses) | Question word + auxiliary + subject + verb | What have you taken? / Who is she talking to? |
Important points:
- In subject questions, the word order is the same as in a normal sentence: Someone broke the window. → Who broke the window?
- Use a singular verb after who and what as the subject, even if the answer is plural: Who wants coffee? (Answer: We all do!)
- Negative subject questions do use don't/doesn't/didn't: Who didn't finish the test?
- With prepositions, the preposition usually goes at the end of object questions: Who did you talk to? What are you looking at? In very formal English: To whom did you speak?
Common mistakes
✗ Who did call you? → ✓ Who called you? Who is the subject, so we don't need did. (Note: did is possible only for strong emphasis, e.g. Well, who did call you, then?)
✗ What did happen? → ✓ What happened? What is the subject of happen. This is one of the most common mistakes.
✗ Who you called yesterday? → ✓ Who did you call yesterday? Who is the object here, so you need did + subject + verb.
✗ Who live in this flat? → ✓ Who lives in this flat? After who as the subject, use a singular verb in the present simple.
✗ How many students did pass the exam? → ✓ How many students passed the exam? How many students is the subject, so no did.
Compare
At B2 level, learners often confuse object questions with indirect questions. In indirect questions (after phrases like Can you tell me… or I don't know…), we use normal word order and no do/does/did.
- Direct: Who did you call? → Indirect: Can you tell me who you called?
- Direct: What does this word mean? → Indirect: Do you know what this word means?
Subject questions don't change their word order: Who called you? → I'd like to know who called you.
This is useful for polite questions in speaking tests like IELTS and CELPIP.
Quick tips
- Ask yourself: is the answer the person who does the action? If yes, don't use do/does/did.
- Make a statement first, then replace the unknown part: Someone ate my cake. → Who ate my cake?
- Remember the very common subject questions: What happened?, Who knows?, What's going on?
- Put prepositions at the end in everyday English: Who are you waiting for?