Modals of deduction
must, might, can't for certainty and guesses.
When to use it
We use modal verbs of deduction to show how sure we are about something. We are not giving facts. We are making a logical guess based on what we see or know.
1. Must: you are almost sure something is true. The lights are on. Someone must be at home. You've worked all day. You must be tired.
2. Might / may / could: you think something is possibly true. She isn't answering. She might be in a meeting. Take an umbrella. It could rain later.
3. Can't / couldn't: you are almost sure something is NOT true. That can't be Tom. He's in Paris this week. She couldn't be the manager. She's only been here two days.
4. Past deductions: modal + have + past participle. The ground is wet. It must have rained last night. He might have missed the bus. She can't have finished already. She only started ten minutes ago.
5. Actions in progress: modal + be + -ing. Don't call now. They might be having dinner. He must have been driving too fast.
How to form it
| Certainty | Present | Past |
|---|---|---|
| Almost sure: yes | must + verb | must have + past participle |
| Possible | might / may / could + verb | might / may / could have + past participle |
| Possibly not | might not / may not + verb | might not / may not have + past participle |
| Almost sure: no | can't / couldn't + verb | can't / couldn't have + past participle |
| Question | Could / Might + subject + verb? | Could / Might + subject + have + past participle? |
Examples of questions: Could he be lying? Might she have forgotten? Who can that be at the door?
Note: In American English, must not is also used for negative deduction: He must not be home. His car is gone. In British English, can't is more usual.
Common mistakes
✗ He mustn't be at work today. I saw him at the beach. → ✓ He can't be at work today. In British English, mustn't means "it is not allowed". For deduction, use can't.
✗ She can be at the library now. → ✓ She could / might be at the library now. Use could or might for a possible guess about a specific situation. Can is for general possibility: Winters can be cold here.
✗ He must forget the meeting yesterday. → ✓ He must have forgotten the meeting yesterday. For the past, use modal + have + past participle.
✗ They might not have seen us, it's impossible. → ✓ They can't have seen us. It's impossible. Might not means "perhaps not". When you are sure, use can't.
✗ It must to be true. → ✓ It must be true. Modal verbs are followed by the base form without to.
Compare
Must for deduction vs. must for obligation You must be hungry. (I am sure you are hungry: deduction.) You must wear a seatbelt. (It is a rule: obligation.)
The negatives are very different: You mustn't park here. (It is not allowed.) That can't be his car. (I am sure it isn't.)
Could have: possibility vs. missed chance At higher levels, notice that could have has two meanings: He could have taken the train. (Maybe he did. I don't know: deduction.) You could have told me! (It was possible, but you didn't: criticism.) The context tells you which meaning is correct.
Quick tips
- Think of a scale: must (90%) → may/might/could (50%) → can't (10% or less).
- Add well to show a stronger possibility: She may well be right. Use possibly to make can't/couldn't stronger: He couldn't possibly have known.
- For the past, always remember the pattern: modal + have + past participle.
- In speaking exams like IELTS, use these forms to describe pictures or guess reasons: This photo must have been taken in winter.