Must, have to, should
Obligation, necessity and advice.
When to use it
1. Must: strong obligation (often the speaker's own feeling, or written rules) Use must when you feel something is very important, or in official rules and signs. - I must call my mum tonight. It's her birthday. - Passengers must wear seat belts at all times.
2. Have to: obligation from outside Use have to when a rule, a person or a situation makes something necessary. - I have to wear a uniform at work. - She has to get up at 6 because her train leaves early.
3. Should: advice or the right thing to do Should is softer than must. It gives an opinion or a recommendation. - You should see a doctor about that cough. - We shouldn't eat so much sugar.
4. Mustn't: something is not allowed - You mustn't smoke in the hospital.
5. Don't have to: something is not necessary You can do it if you want, but there is no obligation. - You don't have to bring food. We have plenty.
6. Past and future obligation Must has no past or future form, so we use had to and will have to. - I had to work late yesterday. - You'll have to show your passport at the border.
7. Should have + past participle: advice about the past (B2) Use it to talk about regret or criticism. The right action did not happen. - I should have studied more for the test. - You shouldn't have said that to her.
How to form it
| Positive | Negative | Question | |
|---|---|---|---|
| must | I must go. | I mustn't go. | Must I go? (formal, rare) |
| have to | She has to go. | She doesn't have to go. | Does she have to go? |
| should | You should go. | You shouldn't go. | Should I go? |
| had to (past) | We had to go. | We didn't have to go. | Did you have to go? |
Key points: - Must and should + base verb (no to). They never change: I must, he must, they must. - Have to works like a normal verb: has to (he/she/it), had to (past), and it uses do/does/did in questions and negatives.
Common mistakes
- ✗ He musts leave now. → ✓ He must leave now. Modal verbs never take -s.
- ✗ You should to rest. → ✓ You should rest. No to after must or should.
- ✗ I musted work yesterday. → ✓ I had to work yesterday. Must has no past form. Use had to.
- ✗ She don't have to pay. → ✓ She doesn't have to pay. Have to follows normal verb rules: does with he/she/it.
- ✗ It's free, so you mustn't pay. → ✓ It's free, so you don't have to pay. Mustn't means "it's forbidden". Don't have to means "it's not necessary".
Compare
Mustn't vs. don't have to In the positive, these two verbs are similar. In the negative, they are completely different. - You mustn't park here. (It is not allowed. Don't do it!) - You don't have to park here. (You can, but you can also park somewhere else.)
Must vs. have to (B1–B2) Both show strong obligation, but: - I must stop eating junk food. (I decided this myself.) - I have to stop eating junk food. My doctor told me. (The obligation comes from outside.)
In everyday spoken English, have to is much more common than must. Must often sounds formal or very personal.
Should vs. must Should is advice; must is a strong obligation. - You should wear a helmet. (It's a good idea.) - You must wear a helmet. (It's the law.)
Quick tips
- In British English, people often say have got to in speech: I've got to go now. It means have to.
- Ought to means the same as should: You ought to apologise. It is a little more formal.
- Must can also show a logical guess: She must be tired. She worked all night. This is not obligation, so look at the context.
- In IELTS or CELPIP writing, add variety with phrases like it is essential to, it is necessary to and people are required to.