Tenses Intermediate Advanced

Present Perfect vs Past Simple

Finished time vs unfinished time and results.

Past Simple: finished time
yesterdayPASTNOWFUTURElost my keys

I lost my keys yesterday.

Present Perfect: result now
PASTNOWFUTUREhave lost my keyskeys still missing

I have lost my keys, so I can't get in.

Present Perfect: unfinished time
this morningPASTNOWFUTUREhave drunk three coffees

I have drunk three coffees this morning.

When to use it

The past simple is for finished time. The action happened at a time that is over, and we often say or know when.

  • A finished action at a stated past time: I visited Toronto in 2019. She called me last night.
  • A story, a list of past events in order: He opened the door, looked around and left.

The present perfect connects the past to now. The time is unfinished, or the result matters now.

  • Unfinished time (today, this week, this year, so far): I've drunk three coffees today.
  • Life experience, when the time is not important: Have you ever been to Japan? I've never failed an exam.
  • A situation that started in the past and continues now (with for and since): We've lived here for ten years.
  • A past action with a present result: I've lost my keys, so I can't get in.
  • Recent news, often with just, already, yet: The train has just arrived.

How to form it

Past simple Present perfect
Positive I worked / I went I have (I've) worked / She has (she's) gone
Negative I didn't work / go I haven't worked / She hasn't gone
Question Did you work / go? Have you worked? / Has she gone?

The present perfect uses have/has + past participle (worked, gone, seen, written). Learn irregular participles carefully: go – went – gone, see – saw – seen.

Common mistakes

  1. ✗ I have seen him yesterday. → ✓ I saw him yesterday.
    Yesterday is finished time, so use the past simple.
  2. ✗ I live here since 2019. → ✓ I have lived here since 2019.
    The situation started in the past and continues now.
  3. ✗ When have you arrived? → ✓ When did you arrive?
    Questions with when ask about a specific past time.
  4. ✗ Shakespeare has written many plays. → ✓ Shakespeare wrote many plays.
    The person is dead, so his life (the time period) is finished.
  5. ✗ I have finished university in 2020. → ✓ I finished university in 2020.
    A year in the past is a finished time.

Compare

Look at these pairs. The verb is the same, but the meaning changes.

  • I've worked here for five years. (I still work here.)
    I worked there for five years. (I don't work there now.)
  • Have you seen the boss this morning? (said at 10 a.m. – the morning is not over)
    Did you see the boss this morning? (said at 4 p.m. – the morning is finished)
  • She's broken her leg. (It's still broken; news or result.)
    She broke her leg when she was ten. (A past event with a time.)

Advanced points (C1–C2):

  • News style: we introduce news with the present perfect, then give details with the past simple. A fire has destroyed a factory in Hamilton. It started at 3 a.m., and firefighters arrived quickly.
  • First time: It's the first time I've eaten sushi (not I eat or I ate).
  • Since + past simple: the clause after since names the starting point, so it is often past simple. I've known her since we were at school.
  • Superlatives: That's the best film I've ever seen.
  • American English often uses the past simple with just, already and yet in informal speech: Did you eat yet? In exams, the present perfect is the safer choice: Have you eaten yet?
  • Writing for IELTS/CELPIP: in a graph description, use the past simple for finished periods (Sales rose in 2015) and the present perfect for trends up to now (Sales have risen since 2015).

Quick tips

  • See a finished time word (yesterday, ago, last year, in 2018, when I was a child)? Use the past simple.
  • See for, since, ever, never, just, already, yet, so far? Think present perfect.
  • Ask yourself: Is the time period over? Over = past simple. Not over or connected to now = present perfect.
  • Start a conversation with the present perfect (Have you ever…?), then switch to the past simple for details (When did you go?).

More on tenses