Defining relative clauses
who, which, that, where, whose.
A defining relative clause gives information that we need to understand which person, thing or place we mean. Without it, the sentence is unclear or has a different meaning.
When to use it
1. To say which person we mean (who / that) - The woman who lives next door is a nurse. - I met a man that speaks six languages.
2. To say which thing or animal we mean (which / that) - The bus which goes to the airport leaves every 20 minutes. - Is this the phone that you lost?
3. To say which place we mean (where) - This is the café where we first met. - I want to live in a city where there is good public transport.
4. To show possession (whose) - She's the student whose essay won the prize. - I know a company whose staff all work from home.
How to form it
Put the relative clause directly after the noun it describes. Do not use commas.
| Word | Used for | Example | Can you leave it out? |
|---|---|---|---|
| who | people | The doctor who helped me was kind. | Only if it is the object |
| which | things, animals | The film which I watched was long. | Only if it is the object |
| that | people or things | The keys that I found are yours. | Only if it is the object |
| where | places | The hotel where we stayed was cheap. | No |
| whose | possession (people and things) | The man whose car was stolen called the police. | No |
Subject or object?
- If the relative pronoun is the subject of the clause, you must keep it: The man who called you is here. (who = the subject of 'called')
- If it is the object, you can leave it out. This is very common in speaking: The man (who) you called is here. (you = the subject; who = the object)
Prepositions (B2 level)
In everyday English, put the preposition at the end: This is the house (that) I grew up in.
In formal writing, you can put the preposition before which or whom: This is the house in which I grew up. After a preposition, use which or whom, never that or who.
Where means 'in/at which', so you can say: the town where I was born = the town (that) I was born in.
Common mistakes
-
✗ This is the book which I bought it yesterday. → ✓ This is the book which I bought yesterday.
The relative pronoun already replaces 'it'. Don't repeat the object. -
✗ The thing what I need is more time. → ✓ The thing that I need is more time.
Don't use what after a noun. Use that or which. -
✗ That's the girl who's father is a pilot. → ✓ That's the girl whose father is a pilot.
Who's = who is. Whose shows possession. -
✗ Paris is the city where I visited last year. → ✓ Paris is the city (that) I visited last year.
Visit needs an object, and where cannot be an object. Use where only when you could say 'in/at that place': the city where I lived. -
✗ The man, who stole my bag, was caught. (when you mean one man out of many) → ✓ The man who stole my bag was caught.
Defining clauses have no commas.
Compare
Defining vs non-defining relative clauses
| Defining | Non-defining |
|---|---|
| Tells us which one; necessary information | Adds extra information; the sentence is clear without it |
| No commas | Commas around the clause |
| That is possible | That is not possible |
| You can leave out the object pronoun | You can never leave out the pronoun |
- My brother who lives in Toronto is a teacher. (I have more than one brother; this one lives in Toronto.)
- My brother, who lives in Toronto, is a teacher. (I have only one brother; the Toronto part is extra information.)
Quick tips
- Ask yourself: Do I need this information to know who or what I mean? If yes, use a defining clause with no commas.
- In speaking, that is the safest and most natural choice for both people and things.
- Leaving out object pronouns (the job I applied for) sounds natural and can help your fluency score in IELTS and CELPIP speaking.
- In formal essays, try in which or to whom to show a wider range of grammar, but use them only when you are sure they are correct.