Clauses & linking Intermediate

Defining relative clauses

who, which, that, where, whose.

A defining relative clause gives information that we need to understand which person, thing or place we mean. Without it, the sentence is unclear or has a different meaning.

When to use it

1. To say which person we mean (who / that) - The woman who lives next door is a nurse. - I met a man that speaks six languages.

2. To say which thing or animal we mean (which / that) - The bus which goes to the airport leaves every 20 minutes. - Is this the phone that you lost?

3. To say which place we mean (where) - This is the café where we first met. - I want to live in a city where there is good public transport.

4. To show possession (whose) - She's the student whose essay won the prize. - I know a company whose staff all work from home.

How to form it

Put the relative clause directly after the noun it describes. Do not use commas.

Word Used for Example Can you leave it out?
who people The doctor who helped me was kind. Only if it is the object
which things, animals The film which I watched was long. Only if it is the object
that people or things The keys that I found are yours. Only if it is the object
where places The hotel where we stayed was cheap. No
whose possession (people and things) The man whose car was stolen called the police. No

Subject or object?

  • If the relative pronoun is the subject of the clause, you must keep it: The man who called you is here. (who = the subject of 'called')
  • If it is the object, you can leave it out. This is very common in speaking: The man (who) you called is here. (you = the subject; who = the object)

Prepositions (B2 level)

In everyday English, put the preposition at the end: This is the house (that) I grew up in.

In formal writing, you can put the preposition before which or whom: This is the house in which I grew up. After a preposition, use which or whom, never that or who.

Where means 'in/at which', so you can say: the town where I was born = the town (that) I was born in.

Common mistakes

  • ✗ This is the book which I bought it yesterday. → ✓ This is the book which I bought yesterday.
    The relative pronoun already replaces 'it'. Don't repeat the object.

  • ✗ The thing what I need is more time. → ✓ The thing that I need is more time.
    Don't use what after a noun. Use that or which.

  • ✗ That's the girl who's father is a pilot. → ✓ That's the girl whose father is a pilot.
    Who's = who is. Whose shows possession.

  • ✗ Paris is the city where I visited last year. → ✓ Paris is the city (that) I visited last year.
    Visit needs an object, and where cannot be an object. Use where only when you could say 'in/at that place': the city where I lived.

  • ✗ The man, who stole my bag, was caught. (when you mean one man out of many) → ✓ The man who stole my bag was caught.
    Defining clauses have no commas.

Compare

Defining vs non-defining relative clauses

Defining Non-defining
Tells us which one; necessary information Adds extra information; the sentence is clear without it
No commas Commas around the clause
That is possible That is not possible
You can leave out the object pronoun You can never leave out the pronoun
  • My brother who lives in Toronto is a teacher. (I have more than one brother; this one lives in Toronto.)
  • My brother, who lives in Toronto, is a teacher. (I have only one brother; the Toronto part is extra information.)

Quick tips

  • Ask yourself: Do I need this information to know who or what I mean? If yes, use a defining clause with no commas.
  • In speaking, that is the safest and most natural choice for both people and things.
  • Leaving out object pronouns (the job I applied for) sounds natural and can help your fluency score in IELTS and CELPIP speaking.
  • In formal essays, try in which or to whom to show a wider range of grammar, but use them only when you are sure they are correct.

More on clauses & linking