Non-defining relative clauses
Extra information with commas.
A non-defining relative clause adds extra information about a person, thing or place that is already clear. If you remove the clause, the sentence still makes sense. We always separate it from the rest of the sentence with commas.
When to use it
1. To add extra facts about a specific person or thing The noun is already identified, often by a name or by my, this or the. My sister, who lives in Vancouver, is a nurse. The Eiffel Tower, which was built in 1889, attracts millions of visitors.
2. To add information about places and times We stayed in Lisbon, where my parents first met. I'll call you on Friday, when I have more time.
3. To comment on a whole idea (C1–C2) Here, which refers to the whole previous clause, not just one noun. He passed the exam on his first try, which surprised everyone. The train was cancelled, which meant we had to take a taxi.
4. To talk about part of a group (C1–C2) Use a quantifier + of whom / of which. I have three brothers, two of whom are engineers. She wrote several reports, none of which were published.
How to form it
The pattern is: noun + comma + relative pronoun + clause + comma (or full stop).
| Pronoun | Used for | Example |
|---|---|---|
| who | people | Mr Lee, who teaches maths, is retiring. |
| whom (formal) | people (object) | Dr Khan, whom I met last year, gave a talk. |
| which | things, animals, whole ideas | My laptop, which is new, keeps crashing. |
| whose | possession | Anna, whose car was stolen, called the police. |
| where | places | Rome, where I studied, is beautiful. |
| when | times | In 2020, when the pandemic started, I worked from home. |
The clause can be negative or in any tense: My boss, who doesn't usually smile, laughed at my joke.
The clause can come in the middle (two commas) or at the end (one comma) of the sentence.
Formal style (C1–C2): put the preposition before whom or which. The committee, to which I sent my application, has not replied. (Formal) The committee, which I sent my application to, has not replied. (Less formal)
Common mistakes
✗ My father, that works in a bank, is very busy. → ✓ My father, who works in a bank, is very busy. We never use that in non-defining clauses.
✗ Ottawa, is the capital of Canada, is cold in winter. → ✓ Ottawa, which is the capital of Canada, is cold in winter. You cannot leave out the relative pronoun in a non-defining clause.
✗ This book, which I bought it yesterday, is great. → ✓ This book, which I bought yesterday, is great. Don't repeat the object; which already replaces it.
✗ She lost her keys, what was annoying. → ✓ She lost her keys, which was annoying. Use which, not what, to comment on a whole idea.
✗ I met ten students, most of them were from Brazil. → ✓ I met ten students, most of whom were from Brazil. Without a conjunction, use of whom / of which to join the clauses. (Or write two sentences.)
Compare
Non-defining vs defining relative clauses
A defining clause tells us which one we mean. It has no commas, and that is possible. The students who studied hard passed. (Only some students passed — the ones who studied.)
A non-defining clause only adds extra information. It has commas, and that is not possible. The students, who studied hard, passed. (All the students passed, and by the way, they all studied hard.)
Another example: My brother who lives in Calgary is a chef. (I have more than one brother.) My brother, who lives in Calgary, is a chef. (I have only one brother.)
The commas change the meaning, so check them carefully in writing tasks.
Quick tips
- Try removing the clause. If the sentence still makes complete sense, you need commas.
- With names (Toronto, Maria), you almost always need a non-defining clause.
- In speech, people make a small pause where the commas are.
- In IELTS or CELPIP writing, use which to comment on an idea (…, which shows that…) and most of whom / many of which to sound more advanced.